Form 1023 Attachments | OPEN GENOMES FOUNDATION, INC. | EIN: 46-2725903 |
Part IV: §1 Purpose and Goals of the
Organization, and Implementation
The association closely follows and exclusively pursues
the goals of a non-profit in accordance with Section 501(c)(3) of the United
States Internal Revenue Code:
- The specific new and until now unmet scientific
requirements and social needs that the not-for-profit Association is
being established to address:
- Technological advances in human genomics and genomic
sequencing are generating a vast amount of genomic sequence data from
individuals
- Unlike the past, much of this genomic sequence data is
being created outside traditional research frameworks
- Sequencing is being purchased directly by
consumers
- Health insurance will begin to pay for genomic
sequencing of all individuals as part of routine diagnostic
screening.
- Individuals who obtain genomic sequence data may want
to share information to the general public and scientific community for
the public benefit, on a timely basis, which relates to their:
- ancestry
- phenotypes
- health
and they are unable to do so now.
- While traditional research frameworks usually require
public availability of the raw data upon which the research is based, the
raw data has not been made available or easily accessible to other
researchers and the general public in many research studies to date
involving genomic sequencing. Additionally, all relevant information is
often not being made available, or easily accessible from the supporting
data.
- Even when genomic research is made available publicly,
there are often expensive fees to access the published studies and
supplementary data.
- The public release of human genomic data has often
been unreasonably delayed because of competing academic and commercial
interests.
- The sharing of genomic data from individuals should
require strict adherence to the international and legal standards of
bioethics for human subjects research, and these requirements have not
been universally observed by the genomics research community. The basic
rights of human research subjects must be respected in all
cases.
- The lack of sharing of human genomic data has resulted
in inaccuracies in forensic data, which creates serious problems with
forensic identification, paternity testing, and the ability of adoptees
to accurately identify their birth parents and ancestral
origins.
- The application of the principles of Open Science
addresses many of these issues. Open Science is defined as making
scientific research data publicly and freely available on a timely basis,
to be used by both researchers and the general public without
restrictions, and with appropriate means for crediting discoveries to the
initial researchers, even before publication. This allows for the rapid
collective utilization of research data by all, and also the ability to
double check and reproduce any research results, thereby helping to
eliminate errors and potential omissions. The non-restrictive nature and
the rapid availability of research data turns the process of scientific
discovery into a collective effort, which greatly accelerates the
process..
- The Association is being founded with the aim of
applying the principles of Open Science to human genomics research. The
coming availability of large amounts of human genomic sequence data from
diverse sources, the need to share this data on a freely available and
timely basis, the need to collectively validate it for accuracy and
completeness, and the sheer complexity of the data which requires a
collective effort to properly analyze and process it, means that an Open
Science approach to human genomics research has become imperative to help
correct the above listed problems in the current situation, and lay the
groundwork for future discoveries in a field that is
becoming critical to improving human health
and the understanding of human history and origins.
- The Association therefore has the following goals and
will accomplish them as follows, in pursuance of the Association’s
tax-exempt purpose:
- Combine the elements of:
- Open Science
- Crowdsourcing (the collective
funding of research)
to enhance basic research in human genomics and save
lives and help communities by using open genomics to improve public health
- Conduct scientific research in the public
interest
- Use public openly accessible human genomic
sequences
- Use sequencing specifically obtained for and/or funded
by the Association
- Associate genomic sequences with all other relevant
information, including:
- ancestry
- history
- historical linguistics
- archaeology
- anthropology
- genealogy
- population genetics
- paleoclimatology
- forensics
- environmental conditions
- diet and nutrition
- microbiology (microbiome and pathogens)
- epidemiology
- pharmacology
- phenotypes
- medical information
- Develop and make available free data
analysis tools and websites
- Use open source genomics software, if
possible
- Develop new analysis tools if the currently available
software does not exist
- Create online systems to analyze and present freely
accessible human genomic data to the scientific community and the
interested public
- Help internationally publicize the results
of research conducted by the Association through:
- Research papers in scientific publications
- Online websites
- Other media accessible to the interested
public
- Using local languages as
appropriate
- Making the results available on a timely basis, with
rapid dissemination of results
- Provide a means for others to sponsor
through crowdsource-funded whole genome sequencing for research in the
public interest, including for people from underserved
communities.
- Encourage crowdsourced sample collection, and
crowdsourced donations of scientific results from genomic sequencing to
be submitted to freely available unrestricted public databases including
the International Nucleotide Sequence Database (which includes the
European Nucleotide Archive and NCBI Genbank)
- Provide a means for laypersons interested in citizen
science to participate in the scientific research process of the study of
human genomics, by encouraging their participation in research alongside
academics and professional researchers. This will provide a way to
rapidly disseminate their ideas and discoveries, and have them published
in a timely manner for the interested public to use without restrictions,
while allowing proper credit for discoveries to be given to the
appropriate people.
- Ensure adherence to the accepted standards of
bioethics in human subjects research while allowing laypeople involved in
citizen science to contribute their knowledge, expertise, volunteer
labor, resources, and their discoveries to the scientific community and
the interested public at large, and for the public good.
- Advocate for the right of people with
genetic disabilities to share their genomic sequences and associated
personal health and ancestry data with researchers and the
interested public, so they can share their results without fear of
unneeded adverse consequences such as genetic discrimination.
- Derive Reconstructed Ancestral Human
Sequences by determining the ancestral and
derived states of each nucleotide in the human genome, thereby making it
possible to:
- Unambiguously identify mutations
including:
- Pathogenic mutations
- Adaptations
- Assemble these Reconstructed Ancestral
Sequences into a chronological series, to create phylogenetic
trees
- Derive accurate mutation rates, which can
be used to develop a DNA molecular clock
- Develop phylogenies of all human non-recombining haploid DNA segments across the
human genomes.
- The phylogenies will be rooted in one or
more Human Ancestral Reference Sequences shared by all living humans on
Earth
- The phylogenetic trees will include all
publicly available sequences, including mutations found in only one
individual. There is no way of knowing whether a given mutation is shared
or truly unique to a single person, and any single mutation in
combination with others may prove to be critical to scientific
research.
- Create population-specific genetic
linkage maps, which show the likelihood of any
single DNA segment recombining in each generation. Accurate linkage maps
facilitate:
- Admixture analysis, the study of the
historical mixing of ancestral populations.
- The calculation of the degree of
relationship between any two individuals using autosomal DNA (Chromosomes
1-22 as opposed to the uniparental markers, the Y chromosome and
mitochondrial DNA).
- Use human genomic phylogenies and open,
freely-accessible, public human genomic data as a tool to help advance research in:
- Population genetics
- Ancestry of
individuals (including adoptees)
- Medical research
- Forensics
- Use human genomic data to research human origins:
- Demonstrate
the fundamental unity of all
mankind
- Discover human history, and
ancestry using archaeogenetics.
- Refute scientific inaccuracies that use
genomic data to support:
- Genetic determinism, where environment and
human ability play no role
- Unscientific myths that divide people, such
as racism, fundamentalist beliefs about human and ethnic origins, and
ethnocentrism
- Oppose unfair commercial exploitation of
closed (proprietary) genomic results for private profit, which inhibits progress in scientific
research.
- While human genomic sequences found in
nature cannot be patented or copyrighted, it is still unclear whether
associated relevant data such as reconstructed ancestral sequences,
phylogenies, and ancestry information can be used in a completely
unrestricted way.
- Ensure that legal and ethical standards of
non-conflict of interest in public and non-profit scientific research are
adhered to and enforced.
- Advocate for the strict adherence to
internationally accepted standards of bioethics in human subjects genomic
research:
- Subjects must give fully informed consent
- Subjects have a right to appeal and redress
against ethical violations
- Researchers must disclose any potential
financial and legal conflicts of interest
- Study results must not be used for
promotion of proprietary commercial genetic tests, or commercial
advertising by sponsors
- Subjects and their communities must not be
subject to undue influence or coercion to participate in
studies
- Researchers must conduct their studies
according to the principle of intellectual integrity. There must be full
disclosure of the all the relevant raw data upon which the study
conclusions are based, in an unrestricted way, and available to the
interested general public. Publication of studies must not be
unreasonably delayed without sufficient cause. All the available data
should be included, and discussed in the study, not withheld or obscured
to support predetermined conclusions.
- As part of the principle of Respect for
Persons in human subjects research, full disclosure must be given to
subjects about any potential political, sectarian, or social conflicts of
interests generated by the uses to which the authors and their sponsors
put the results, such as changing immigration, citizenship, land rights,
or personal status (e.g. marriage) policies in areas of the world where
these are tied to one's ethnic or sectarian origin. This will help avoid
biocolonialism and attempts to use scientific research as justifications
for discrimination against ethnic minorities or other vulnerable
populations.
- Promote the idea of routine phased whole genome sequencing, and help make it available to
the general public:
- Provided at the lowest cost possible
- To be conducted whenever possible on a non-profit
basis
- With minimal operating overhead
- Advocate for the right of all individuals to receive
routine genomic sequencing as part of a general baseline health
screening
- Make certain that individuals have unrestricted access
to their own complete genomic sequencing data
- Individuals should have the right to make their
genomic sequences and all other associated relevant information available
to the scientific community and the interested public on a timely basis,
without restrictions
- Make human genomic sequences publicly
available and accessible for scientific research by
submitting them to the International Nucleotide Sequence Database (which
includes the European Nucleotide Archive and NCBI Genbank), and encourage
others to follow suit. The International Nucleotide Sequence Database is
a consortium of the EU, US and Japanese governments designed to store
genomic sequences fulfilling the following requirements, which uniquely
meet the Open Science goals of the Association:
- A universal repository for all genomic sequence
data
- Not controlled by any one commercial entity or
country
- Submissions of genomic sequences are accepted from all
sources and are permanently stored without charge
- All data is freely available to the public and the
research community, without fees or copyright restrictions
- Promote the idea that individuals who were
already tested should make their existing genomic sequence data available
in the International Nucleotide Sequence Database (INSD),
and provide a means for the general public, customers of direct to
consumer DNA testing services, and individuals who have had subsidized
medical sequencing, to submit their sequences to the INSD.
- Associate different data sets and test results from
the same individual under a single entry or code for that
individual
- Optionally group results from related individuals
under a single entry for the pedigree
- Provide a free means for individuals to optionally
associate information about their ancestry, phenotype and health
information with their genomic sequences, while providing a means for
individuals to achieve the level of privacy and anonymity that they wish
to maintain
- Utilize a variety of genomic sequencing
technologies to obtain more accurate results, through the
comparative sequencing of samples provided by the Association.
- Genomic sequencing using a variety of different
innovative technologies will help determine accurate phased genomic
sequences across entire chromosomes, including
regions that are hard to uniquely align today, such as
copy-number variations, palindromic regions, interrupts and regions that
are homologous with other chromosomes
- Associate the sequencing results obtained from a
single biological source individual and make these sequences public in
the International Nucleotide Sequence Database. This will allow the
interested public to directly compare results for the same individual.
Current sequencing technologies have different strengths and weaknesses,
and different error rates. An additive comparison of the results of
different technologies for the same individual will leverage the
advantages of each, and the additive result will be much more accurate
than the individual results we see today.